Listen Up! Top Five Things Lawyers Wish Boards Knew

 While some condos and HOAs are lucky enough to have lawyers serve as members of  their board, the majority of boards don’t have an in-house legal expert. They often reach out to their attorney to  answer questions, vet documents, send the occasional stern letter to a  contractor or recalcitrant resident, and handle any litigation that’s not avoidable by other means.  

 The problem is that sometimes the board will reach out too often, calling  attorneys about things the board should already know, or which have nothing to  do with the lawyer, or that are just variations of the same questions that are  asked over and over. Then there are those boards that don’t call their lawyers enough, and try to do things on their own that they really  shouldn’t be.  

 It depends on the lawyer and the attorney-client relationship, but a competent  lawyer needs to be prepared to give difficult advice to the board members if  the actions are not in the best interest of the association.  

 We polled some area lawyers to come up with a list of the “Top 5 Things Attorneys Wish Boards Knew.”  

 Who You Gonna Call?

 Often times, boards make the mistake of taking legal matters into their own  hands in an effort to save funds. However, this is a misstep that can lead to  financial woes much greater than the cost of professional counsel.  

 “Every association should have an attorney upon whom they can rely for advice,” Mark Roth, an attorney and partner with the Chicago law firm of Orum & Roth, LLC, says. “A good attorney well-versed in association law will generally save the  association much more than the cost of that lawyer’s advice. Most experienced association attorneys are able to answer a board’s more routine questions in a relatively short period of time. Boards should  consult their association attorney before a contemplated actions is taken— not after,” he adds.  

 What good is having proper representation if you don't take full advantage of  it? While your attorney is surely an expert on all things community association  related, he or she is not omniscient. It's therefore vital for boards to keep  counsel updated on any questions or concerns members might have. Doing so can  prevent unnecessary litigation expenses in the long run.  

 “There’s no such thing as a bad question, or a dumb question when it comes to what the  declaration provides or what the rules provide,” says James Stevens, senior counsel at the law firm of Tressler LLP in  Bolingbrook. “A lot of times, I’ll see perfectly well-intentioned boards go down the wrong path when the  declaration requires something else—maybe doing something at an owner’s meeting versus a board meeting, and not seeing that distinction. And  unfortunately, we might have to go back and the board might have to redo its  decision when a very simple question could have been asked.”  

 Legal counsel is not the only guidance a board needs. Charles M. Keough, a  partner with the law firm of Keough & Moody, PC in Chicago, recommends hiring added help such as an engineer and an  accountant.  

 According to attorney Sima L. Kirsch, whose practice is Sima L. Kirsch PC in  Chicago, “Hire a professional for specialty specific work. A board is not expected to do  all of the work, only to oversee that the work being done is accurate. A board  should have a financial expert (CPA) to consult and rely upon—with assets and liabilities that belong to everyone, they shouldn’t play around.”  

 “You can rely on your attorney's opinion,” Kirsch says. “The Business Judgment Rule protects boards that rely on legal advice given by  their counsel. Board members should take advantage of this whenever possible. A  board that understands and applies the business judgment rule with their  practices is a best practices board.”  

 Change it Up

 Boards might find themselves stuck in a rut due to following previous members'  footsteps too closely. Don't get caught in the trap of picking up old members'  bad habits. If something is broken, fix it, Kirsch urges,  

 “Just because the previous board did it does not mean it is correct,” Kirsch says. “When a transition occurs, the new board cannot escape its fiduciary duty by  merely saying, 'That's the way we've always done it.' A transition review of  the state of the corporation and its operational systems is an exercise in best  practices.”  

 Kirsch also recommends keeping on top of operating documents, and recommends  revising them before an issue arises.  

 “Many associations’ operating documents are outdated and/or contain provisions unfriendly to  current circumstances,” he says. “It is difficult to get enough votes to amend them when no issue exists and  almost impossible when a community becomes divided over an issue.”  

 A Failure to Communicate

 As any couples' counselor will say, strong and steady communication is essential  to a successful relationship. This sentiment applies to the board/owners  relationship as well.  

 “Communication is key—no one likes to get blindsided,” Kirsch says. “Owners are more likely to accept changes when they are aware of them from the  beginning, have an opportunity to become involved in a dialogue, and understand  the basis of the decision.” “While transparency is a best practice,” he continues, “the board should not release its internal discussions or opinions. State the  issue, open it for discussion, have a second discussion, if needed and then  take the vote.”  

 This leads to a frequently asked question: What is the best way for a board to  be transparent?  

 Be Transparent

 The best way to ensure owners feel like they are clued in to the happenings of  the association is to make meetings as open and accessible as possible, Roth  says. This includes not holding meetings unannounced to owners and making  minutes available, whether it be through publishing minutes on a website,  posting them on the property or sending them via email at owners' request.  

 Before sending out meeting minutes, make sure they are drafted correctly, as to  minimize confusion and maximize clarity.  

 “Board meeting minutes should contain such standard information such as the date,  start time and end time, and place of the meeting; and the board members who  attended or were absent,” Roth says. “The meeting minutes should contain motions, votes and points of order. Finally,  if there is an important, potentially contentious decision one board member may  want to explain the thought process behind the board’s decision. For example, if the board is voting to take out a loan to pay for a  project, the board may want to explain the results of any professional  inspections necessitating the project, the number of lenders that the  association contacted to discuss loan terms, the general terms of those loan  proposals and the rationale for selecting the particular lender. That  information may properly be included in the board minutes.”  

 Setting boundaries with owners is another important step in creating and  maintaining transparency.  

 “Remind owners you’re not required to have a consensus,” Kirsch says. “To do this, re-set expectations. Create clear regulations and policies to  establish uniformity of operation that works for your group. Explain you’re going to follow the operating documents, the law and best practices. Have an  annual session for this purpose and lay it all out. If the group understands  what is happening and what is expected, many issues fall away. Remind them, if  they want to know more or have more input they can sign up for a committee or  even run for the board.”  

 Choose a


 Want to know what irks a lawyer almost more than anything? It’s when several people from a board call about the same matter or when three  different board members reach out on the same day to discuss three different  issues.  

 “I think a liaison can be very useful as long as that person is diligent about  sharing the attorney’s feedback with the other board members and that the person is also diligent  about getting input from the other board members too,” Stevens says. “You don’t want to have the attorney liaison from the board be the only person that knows  what’s going on with legal concerns. It can be very helpful and does save some  attorney time because there are not 45 different questions coming in from each  board member. The communication has to be free flowing both ways for it to  really work well.”  

 By doing so, it provides a much more structured flow of information to the board  and keeps the attorney better in the loop.   

 .Keith Loria is a freelance writer and a frequent contributor to The Chicagoland  Cooperator.  

Related Articles

Vinyl waterproof flooring in two story open great room with tall windows

Home Staging

What Really Sells an Apartment

Financial, Physical, & Operational Health

Financial, Physical, & Operational Health

How Does Your Association Measure Up?

Retail space available for sale or lease in colorful old building in Greenwich Village in New York

Ground Floor Commercial Space

A Soft Market = Lower Rents, More Vacancies